by Mark Lavercombe, published on 27th April 2008|
The first film starring Ellen Page to be released in Australia post-Juno was always likely to suffer by comparison to that brilliant gem, and unfortunately Smart People meets that expectation.
Dennis Quaid is Lawrence Wetherhold, a literature professor teaching at Carnegie Mellon University and attempting to get his rather dry book on critical theory published by a large publisher. In spite of being tenured he seems to have lost his interest in teaching and his students know it.Smart People (Am ende kommen Touristen) When a head injury brings him into contact with a former student turned medico Dr Janet Hartigan (played by Sarah Jessica Parker), his failure to move on emotionally after the death of his first wife is brought into sharp relief and Wetherhold must confront the unhappiness he and his family live with on a daily basis.
Although Quaid is fair as the grizzled Wetherhold, the romance he is supposedly developing with Hartigan is a complete non-starter. This isn't the first film in which a character played by Parker is almost entirely devoid of charisma such that her relationship(s) seem artificial (another recent example is The Family Stone), and in Smart People this lack of spark between Hartigan and Wetherhold is critical.
Page and Thomas Haden Church do manage a degree of believable interaction as Wetherhold's daughter and adopted brother respectively, but the decision to insert a crisis in their relationship - however useful it may have been felt by the writers in terms of developing their characters - means the film is robbed of the one relationship with any interest. Page nails her role as the rather appalling Vanessa, although she may have been better off choosing a less eloquent character to allow audiences to see another side of her ability after Juno and Hard Candy. Haden Church may also wish to review his role selection given the proximity of this performance to his best-to-date in Sideways.
Aside from the failure to engage the audience that essentially dooms the film as a romantic drama, or perhaps because of it, Smart People justs feels so lacklustre. The slow-moving plot and character development suggest something deeper to say, however the audience may well be too anaesthetised to appreciate its subtleties. The insertion of yet another Haden Church bum-shot certainly doesn't liven things up enough to compensate.
Parker's appearance in another dull film does nothing to support her claim she can adequately lead on the big screen in spite of the enormous success in her small screen career, but the near-certain success of Sex and the City later this year may allow her the breathing space to get one last shot at breaking through in a character other than Carrie. Let's hope her choices improve.
Rating: 2 out of 4
Hoopla Factor: 2 out of 4