English German
Quick Links

The opinions, comments and viewpoints expressed in articles are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the webmaster.

All press articles are still under copyright from the original source and provided for entertainment purposes and research only. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for your own purposes beyond the 'fair use' exception, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

» Exclaim.ca Movie Review - The Stone Angel

by Travis Mackenzie Hoover, published in June 2008

There’s a reason Margaret Laurence’s flagship novel became the CanLit chestnut we know today. For all your groaning over having to read it in high school, it’s a remarkably complex work. Hagar Shipley goes on her destructive way as she resists convention, marries the wrong man and then makes her children pay for her mistakes. And one begrudgingly admires her for plugging away for the happiness that always eludes her.

But the new movie — updated to the present and starring Ellen Burstyn as the older Hagar — lacks the ambiguity, carnality and sheer guts of Laurence’s vision. As with the novel, the film jumps back and forth between the old Hagar’s encroaching internment in a nursing home and the apparently misspent life leading up to that event, but where the book had an intricate manner of blending past and present, the film is haphazard and clumsy. But the problem is more than technical.

Entrusted with making a movie that will play to a genteel audience, director Kari Skogland has stripped the novel of its most painful elements — what was a screaming fury in Laurence is now a blip of disappointment, and the heroine’s refusal to say die is less the act of a misguided person giving life her all than that of a petty schmuck ripe for judgment.

It’s well enough made and Christine Horne does well as Hagar’s younger incarnation but what’s here is unoriginal and offers no personal perspective on the work being rendered.

This is the kind of cinematic gentrification of a literary source that manages to do a disservice to both literature and cinema, making the latter into a medium for the taming of the former. (Alliance)

Source: www.exclaim.ca

Printerfriendly version · Read 3319 times

Last Update: 02/20/2020 Twitter  Facebook  YouTube  Instagram  Tumblr  Privacy Policy GDPR  HiStats  Facebook Group Ellen Page Fans © 2006-2020 TeamEPO
news ellenpage career media interact site web fancorner profile biography quotes factsandtrivia faqs filmography demoreel awards charity otherprojects gallery videoclips audioclips messageboard fanarts fanlisting guestbook links listedat affiliates aboutepo changelog contact epofaqs legalnotice