by David Sugarman, published on Friday, April 16, 2010|
The opening scene of Whip It! introduces Bliss Cavender (Ellen Page) preparing for a beauty pageant by dying her hair blue, much to her mother's (Marcia Gay Harden) horror when Bliss later steps up onto the podium. It's an amusing moment, but feels more than a little like something's missing: that perhaps this should have been preceded by another scene, that there's something we need to have been told for this to work. It's a feeling that nags away throughout the film.
Widely publicized as the directorial debut of American actress Drew Barrymore (also appearing in front of the lens) Whip It! plays out as an enjoyable - if lightweight - coming-of-age drama which follows protagonist Bliss (Page), a teenager who discovers a passion for the somewhat baffling sport of Roller Derby. Ill be honest; having sat through the entirety of Whip It!, Im still non-the-wiser as to how the mechanics of Roller Derby indeed work, though several attempts are made to explain it. Thankfully, this isnt a prerequisite before watching and indeed several of the films most memorable scenes take place on the track.
Bliss joins the Hurl Scouts, a failing team composed entirely of teenage women with slightly threatening nicknames (their real names never being revealed) including Maggie Mayhem (Kristen Wiig), Rosa Sparks (Eve), Bloody Holly (Zoe Bell), and captain, Smashley Simpson (played by director Barrymore). Smashley becomes a perfect comedic vehicle for the director, who spends much of her screen time on the floor, wrestling. From what I managed to garner, this is not an allowable move in Roller Derby.
Bliss reveals a natural talent for the sport and her apparent youth and beauty swiftly puts her into direct conflict with opposing team leader, Iron Maven (Juliette Lewis). The films handling of conflict, whether between Bliss and Maven or Bliss and her mother, is somewhat slight and untenable and is easily identifiable as one of Whip It!s most evident flaws.
Even more problematic is the films romantic subplot which sees Bliss involving herself with local rock musician Oliver (Landon Pigg); a floppy-haired, glassy-eyed young man whose band is hoping to hit big. There's not enough in the script to really suggest their relationship is as strong as the film would have us believe and Pigg's poor delivery of mediocre dialogue merely serves to draw credibility away from the whole scenario.
Unfortunately, the film is neither as consistently funny nor as charming as it would like to think; yet Pages sincere performance brings some extra gravitas to an otherwise unremarkable script. At times, Whip It! feels more like a children's film with the addition of swearing and bodily fluids, than a child-like film for adults. The movie's attempt to capture (and imitate) the success of Page's breakout hit Juno quickly becomes all too obvious. This is Whip It! at its worst; at its best its an enjoyable teen film, unfortunately lacking in several key departments.